For a bookkeeping scandal that generated 13bn of writedowns and wiped $15bn off market well worth, a recommended settlement of $1bn appears skimpy.

But steinhoff, the disgraced south african retail group, is scarcely in a position to splash a lot hard cash. the real payout to people is in painfully won wisdom. maybe not for there's nothing steinhoffs biggest backer and erstwhile chairman christo wiese understood in the south african press as previous billionaire.

If a companys accounts look too-good to be true, they probably tend to be. in case it is hard to discern a strategy in a string of disparate, costly purchases, the acquirer may not have one beyond maintaining the income going.

Under new management steinhoff, which can be placed in frankfurt and johannesburg, has actually sold devices including its british furniture retailing company. but it still has $10bn in debt and faces 90 multi-jurisdictional lawsuits with quantified damages of 7bn.

Steinhoff purchased eclectic foreign assets including an us mattress company and a sequence of uk pound stores throwing down over 1bn in profits a-year. deloitte after that declined to sign off the accounts. a subsequent report by pwc found an alleged 6.5bn fraudulence concerning the development of fictitious or irregular earnings distributed among underperforming subsidiaries.

Those overlooked of pocket have traditionally already been pursuing redress. a team of over 100 lenders includes the european central bank, which purchased into a 800m bond issue. a lot of your debt has become in the hands of professionals in troubled bonds and financial loans. steinhoff wants investors to accept easier terms.

If settlement experiences, steinhoff will fund it with rands 13bn ($800m) of cash on its balance sheet and stock in pepkor, a retailer steinhoff bought from mr wiese using its own stocks in 2014.

Money would mark a milestone in teams rehabilitation and then leave it right back mostly in which it began grounded in south africa, the difficult economic climate it was wanting to diversify from. investors who finally obtain redress are going to be forgiven for perhaps not reinvesting it in the organization.

Lex recommends the fts due diligence publication, a curated briefing regarding the realm of mergers and purchases. view here to register.